In 2004, California became the first state to mandate minimum nurse staffing levels for various nursing units. The mandates were specifically designed to regulate how many patients a nurse could care for at any one time. As other states start to look at legislation or regulations, they are using California as an example. With the new healthcare reform act in place more people, who have not been seeking medical assistance due to the lack of health insurance, will clearly increase the patient load on nurses.
Currently New Jersey and Pennsylvania do not have legislation regarding the nurse-patient ratio. Nurse researchers, led by Linda Aiken, R.N., Ph.D., University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing, compared the outcomes for nurses and quality of care in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and California.
A total of 22,336 nurses in all three states were surveyed and the patient outcome was examined. The patient outcome included 30-day inpatient mortality and failure-to-rescue across hospitals according to whether the nurses cared for fewer or more patients each.
The key findings in the research were:
- Nurse workloads in New Jersey and Pennsylvania on all types of units were above the California-mandated staffing level.
- If New Jersey and Pennsylvania matched California nurse staffing ratio, New Jersey hospitals would have a patient death decrease of 13.9 percent and Pennsylvania would have a decrease of 10.6 percent.
The expanded issue for New Jersey is the state has a shortage of nurses. In February 2010, Acting Governor Stephen M. Sweeney signed the Nursing Faulty Load Redemption Program Act into law. The state senate passed the bill unanimously and declared the nursing workforce shortage of “crisis proportions.” Part of the explanation of the nurse shortage is due to a shortage of faculty members at the state’s schools of nursing.
The new law calls for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation New Jersey Nursing Initiative (NJNI) to work with the Higher Education Student Assistance Authority to create incentives for persons to enter nursing programs by providing loan redemption in exchange for full-time employment in the state as a nurse faculty member.
“In New Jersey, and elsewhere, we are facing a debilitating shortage of nurse faculty, and as a result many of our schools of nursing are being forced to turn away qualified students who want to become nurses,” said Susan Bakewell-Sachs, Ph.D., R.N., P.N.P.-B.C., program director for NJNI and dean of the School of Nursing, Health, and Exercise Science at the College of New Jersey. “With so many nurses at or near retirement, the population aging, the new healthcare reform act, and chronic diseases affecting more people, our state’s health care system will be strained to the breaking point.
The program will address the nurse faculty shortage by providing incentives for individuals to purse masters and doctoral degrees in nursing. Upon graduation, the program will provide loan redemption in exchange for full-time faculty employment for five years at a school of nursing in the state of New Jersey.
The results of lower nurse-to-patient ratios are clear, but some states are realizing their shortage of nurses and the potential increase in numbers of patients, due to the new healthcare reform laws, could turn catastrophic for their state.